In late 2022, the seventh paper from the Varieties of Contemplative Experience (VCE) project was published. Entitled The roles and impacts of worldviews in the context of meditation-related challenges, the paper was authored by Jared Lindahl, Roman Palitsky, David Cooper, and Willoughby Britton, and was published in the journal Transcultural Psychiatry.
Cult Mediation Specialist Patrick Ryan discusses how cults operate and how to intervene when someone needs help.
Far from being a meditation method that’s misleadingly sold as “not a religion,” almost every element of the program, from its marketing, its initiation or instruction methods, and its advanced programs, are of a “religious nature,” fundamentally suspect, and are offered by an organization that isn’t trustworthy. Its internally toxic, cultish, sexist nature is well known among those formerly involved, who’ve experienced firsthand the practices and habits common among the movement’s lifelong devotees.
studies report observations that challenge the validity of the TM
movement’s doctrinal stance; for example, a Ph.D. thesis (D, MIU,
1989, T735.494, in the MIU library) called The Transcendental Meditation
technique: A new direction for smoking cessation programs. In this
study, 60 percent of smokers who began TM and were still practicing
TM twice daily after 20 months, quit smoking. TM may help someone
to quit smoking if the individual stays with the practice for 20 months
29.7 percent were no longer meditating, 38.2 percent were occasional
practitioners, 13.3 percent practiced TM once a day, and only 18.8
percent still practiced TM twice daily as instructed. Some people
have long suspected that it is inaccurate for the TM movement to base
assertions regarding the number of people who practice TM on the numbers
of people who have been instructed. Now there is hard data in the
MIU library that confirms this suspicion–in the MIU library–until
this newsletter is published, that is, because the MIU administration
does have a practice of removing books not supportive of doctrinal
claims made by the TM organization, as was observed and verified by
Albert Miller in 1989.
which was published in the March 1989 edition of the American Journal
of Physiology (p. R632) reports on the most in-depth study to date
on the effects of TM on respiration (breathing) and metabolic rate
(level of rest). Even using long-term meditators as subjects, including
Purusha [full time male staff] members, the authors had to conclude
that TM resulted in no greater level of rest than was observed in
controls who sat with their eyes closed. Kesterson and Clinch also
state in their paper that TMers reached the deepest levels of rest
while lying down after TM, not while practicing TM.
teachings, enlightenment, from a physiological perspective, is said
to be gained by release of stress and normalization of the nervous
system due to deep rest in TM; the rest is said to be unique and deeper
than sleep at night.
what’s the new explanation for how it produces enlightenment on a
physiological level? There isn’t one. TM administrators haven’t had
to provide a new understanding: Instead they suppressed the findings
of Kesterson and Clinch’s study through selective inattention.
These two MIU researchers did find a physiological indicator of TM,
but it is not one that a TM person would expect. In their subjects
practicing TM, but not in control subjects, they observed a slight
decrease in respiratory exchange ration, which indicates a probable
increased retention of carbon dioxide (usually considered to be a
waste product) by subjects during TM.
Washington Counsel for American Family Foundation (AFF) and Cult Awareness Network (CAN)
calls himself Maharishi Mahesh Yogi. His devotees adore him, simply, as
“Maharishi.” He sells Transcendental Meditation, with a capital “M.”
It differs from many kinds of small “m” meditation. So better examine
it carefully before you buy.
He lives reclusively on a luxury estate in Holland, far from the tax
collectors of his former headquarters, in India, Switzerland and the
U.S.A. But Maharishi’s agents are again in Washington, D.C., hunting
for government funds to propagate TM and donations from unwary individu-
state would be unlawful because TM is a religion — not the science it
pretends to be. Donations would be unwise because TM can harm people in
the large doses Maharishi promotes though it carries no warning labels.
_Malnak_v._Yogi_, 440 F.Supp. 1284 (1977), _affirmed_, 592 F.2d 197 (3rd
Cir. 1979). Government funding to propagate TM is therefore unconstitu-
Welfare (HEW) and the New Jersey Department of Education funded an “ex-
periment” to teach TM and its “Science of Creative Intelligence”
(TM/SCI) as an elective in five public high schools. Teachers
specially-trained by TM taught students four or five days a week. If it
“worked” the course would be taught state-wide.
group based in Berkeley, California) and Americans United for Separation
of Church and State asked the U.S. District Court for New Jersey to
enjoin this experiment. These plaintiffs argued that TM was a religion
and that the teaching of TM in public schools and the government funding
were both an “Establishment of Religion” in violation of the First Amendment to the Constitution. TM representatives argued that TM is a
secular science, not a religion.
HEW Secretary Joseph A. Califano, Jr., N.J. Commissioner Fred G. Burke,
school officials and TM’s umbrella organization itself from using public
funds to propagate TM. The Third Circuit Court of Appeals in Philadel-
phia unanimously affirmed. Judge Meanor’s injunction is still in effect
which was being taught, and the religious nature of his _puja_ initia-
tion ceremony which TMers must go through individually to receive their
secret meditation mantra. Without that mantra it is impossible to prac-
each student brought some fruit, flowers and a clean white handkerchief
which were taken and laid on a table in a closed room. The student’s
teacher would bow and make offerings many times to an 8″ by 12″ color
photograph of Guru Dev, said to be Maharishi’s teacher, who had died in
the 1950s. Each student’s teacher also sang a chant in Sanksrit and the
student received “his own personal mantra which is never to be revealed
to any other person.” 592 F.2d at 198.
gratitude to teachers. However, Judge Meanor read an English transla-
tion _prepared_by_TM_ and found not one word of thanks in it. Rather,
the chant describes a deified Guru Dev as “the Lord” and “Him” (with a
capital aitch), among a slew of divine epithets quoted by Judge Meanor.
in all creation, . . . to Him, to Shri Guru Dev, I bow down.
. . . .
the Eternal, the Pure, the Immovable, . . . to Shri Guru Dev,
I bow down.
who practiced TM, testified that TM and the _puja_ chant had no reli-
gious meaning — even after they had read TM’s English translation.
For example, Rabbi Harry Essrig of Los Angeles practiced TM, recommended
it to his congregants, called it “primarily a scientific technique,”
studied Maharishi’s SCI and somehow found no conflict between his own
religion and either the translated text or the accompanying ceremony.
In sharp contrast, Rabbi Seymour Siegel, Professor of Theology at the
Jewish Theological Seminary in New York City, swore that in “the cul-
tural setting of the United States and in the tradition of both Hebrew
and Christian theology” such terms are “descriptive exclusively of a
Supreme Being or God.”
_Yogi_ extensively excerpts Maharishi’s “scientific” SCI textbook and
reprints the full text of his _puja_ ceremony chant.
Heinz R. Pagels, Ph.D., Executive Director of The New York Academy of
Sciences prepared an affidavit on behalf of ex-TMer Robert Kropinski in
1986 for a court case here in Washington, D.C. Pagels wrote as a “theo-
retical physicist specializing in the area of quantum field theory”:
ature issued by [TM] that purport to find a connection between the
recent ideas of theoretical physics — unified field theory, the
vacuum state and collective phenomena — and states of conscious-
ness attained by transcendental meditation are false and pro-
foundly misleading. No qualified physicist that I know would
claim to find such a connection without knowingly committing
ation. How could that really hurt you (even if how-to lessons and “your
own” secret mantra were overpriced at $600)?
$2,000) that Maharishi began to sell in the late 1970s. Advanced TMers
meditate for _hours_ at a time. That can stimulate delusions and hallu-
sons may cost $3,000.) TMers don’t really fly. They hop, from a cross-
legged yoga position. They develop awesomely powerful thigh muscles.
They may develop aches. After hop, hop, hopping across a room, TMers
coming out of their altered mental state may believe that they flew even
though it never happened. Major TV programs have shown how “flying”
TMers really hop. You can borrow a video tape to see for yourself.
teacher and yogic flyer Diane Hendel:
tion periods. . . . They were like my pets. They’d tell me
things.” Hendel was encouraged to believe that these winged beas-
ties were “devas” — Hindu spirits of nature. “I began not to be
able to tell who was a person and who was a deva,” she said. Hen-
del sought counseling, eventually quit meditating, and left the
sonalities crushed and buried, devoid of emotion. In some cases, the
meditator may go into involuntary meditation — which could be devastat-
ing if driving a car or at many kinds of jobs. Stanford psychologist
Leon S. Otis (who believed many people could benefit from the 20-minute
relaxation) concluded that his data raise serious doubts about the innocuous nature of TM.
In fact, they suggest that TM may be hazardous to the mental
health of a sizable proportion of the people who take up TM.
_Journal_of_New_Religious_Movements_, 9, 37-50 (1985).
ssing” when symptoms of distress accompany his meditation. Ex-TMers
have sued TM, alleging severe harms. TM has generally settled out of
court, including cases in Washington, D.C.
by meditation and so instruct potential initiates as well as to provide
guidelines to both the general public and the psychotherapeutic profes-
sion for their amelioration.” An ethical guru would prepare for harmful
side effects, and would immediately instruct sufferers to ease off on
their meditation. Instead of “warning labels” about harmful side
effects, however, Maharishi taught his aides to welcome adverse symptoms
as evidence of “unstressing” — and to encourage even more intensive
claims all kinds of marvelous “Maharishi effects” when it is performed
by masses of meditators. It is hard to keep up with TM’s claims for
mass meditation. TM’s “intellectual” center at Fairfield, Iowa, called
“Maharishi International University” (MIU) churns them out.
poured for buildings (the “Domes”) in which hundreds could meditate.
A dispassionate study showed that the concrete contractor checked the
National Weather Forecast each time before deciding to make a deliv-
ery the next day and that the meditators sought warm weather only
later in the day, after the forecast on which the contractor relied
was already made. Trumpy, “An Investigation of the Reported Effect
of Transcendental Meditation on the Weather,” _The_Skeptical_Inquir-
er_, VIII, 143 (Winter 1983/84).
the crime rate would go down. In Fairfield, Iowa, 13% of the popula-
tion meditates, yet crime has not gone down. Randi, _Flim-Flam_,
cited in _Rational_Enquirer_, newsletter of the BC Skeptics (Van-
couver April 1989).
about social benefits including “a solution to conflicts in the
region that were impossible of solution until now.” Mordecai Kaff-
man, Director of the Research Department of the Kibbutz Child and
Family Clinic, dismissed TM methods as unscientific and TM “claims of
positive results in the Israeli context” as unconvincing; he branded
dental Meditation to Promote Social Progress in Israel,” _Cultic_Stu-
dies_Journal_, 3:1 (1986).
varieties of the “New Age” movement in America. He discusses TM in
chapter 6 of _Heaven_on_Earth_-_Dispatches_from_America’s_Spiritual_
_Frontier_ (Crown, 1992). As a friend of the New Age, who wanted to
find something positive in TM, D’Antonio concludes:
spirituality that was consistent with reason. But TM, as it is
practiced at MIU, isn’t a middle ground.
worried that I was observing a cult rather than a culture. . . .
MIU and the Maharishi would take control of everything — right
down to matters of food, shelter, and child-rearing — for the
security. Far from being a place where individuals grow and inno-
vate, the Fairfield TM community is regimented and constricted. .
. . All conflict, doubt, perhaps even all genuine emotion, is
stifled and covered over with a pleasant veneer.
default rates for all universities and other participating insti-
tutions in the country. MIU was listed as a 5-year private insti-
tution with 175 student loan borrowers in 1992, of whom 12.9% were
in default (the highest default rate of any 4 or 5 year college or
university in Iowa). As a taxpayer, you are already subsidizing
MIU. Think twice before giving TM any more.
Permission to copy with attribution is hereby granted.
World Government of the Age of Enlightenment
World Plan Executive Council – U.S. (WPEC-US) – umbrella
International Meditation Society – listed on brochures as Educational Service of World Plan Executive Council”
Students International Meditation Society
American Association for Ideal Education – copyright holder on recent brochures (1991)
Spiritual Regeneration Movement Foundation (1959)
Age of Enlightenment Press
MIU PressSchools – Colleges – UniversitiesMaharishi International University (Fairfield, Iowa, USA) –
accredited by the North Central Association of Colleges
and Schools. Organizations based at MIU:Institute for Law, Consciousness and the Science of Creative Intelligence (1979)
Institute of World Leadership (1983)
Institute for Science, Technology, and Public Policy
Maharishi Institute of Management
American Association for Ideal Education – copyright holder on recent brochures (1991)
MIU College of Natural Law – the now defunct college based in Washington, DC; was licensed by the DC Educational Institution Licensure Commission, according to an MIU brochure (1982)
Maharishi European Research University, Seelisberg, Switzerland – alleged to be a few desks in the movement’s hotel there
Maharishi University of Natural Law, Mentmore Towers, Buckinghamshire England – is officially unrecognized.
Maharishi Vedic University – A corporate entity that has no campus, no course catalogue and no students
Maharishi Ayur-Vedic University – is a heading in MIU’s gopher server, status unknown
Maharishi School of the Age of Enlightenment, Age of Enlightenment School – Elementary and secondary schools for grades K-12 in Fairfield and Washington, DCCenters / Informal Groups / Etc.
Capital of the Age of Enlightenment, World Plan Center – the local TM center
Ideal Village Council
Association of Executive Governors
Global Television, Inc. – Former owner of KSCI(TV), Channel 18, San Bernadino (Los Angeles), CA
For-profit Corporations and Projects
Maharishi Ayur-Veda Products Inc, Lancaster, Massachusetts, USA
Maharishi Heaven on Earth Development Corporation
American City Project
Natural Law Party
Maharishi European Council of Natural Law Parties
Compiled by Mike Doughney, firstname.lastname@example.org