cult recovery 101

Should I Stay or Should I Go? Religious (Dis)Affiliation and Depressive Symptomatology

Should I Stay or Should I Go? Religious (Dis)Affiliation and Depressive Symptomatology

Matthew May

Oakland University, Rochester, MI, USA
Sage Journals
Society and Mental Health
December 29, 2017

Religious affiliation is generally associated with better mental health. The nonreligious, however, currently constitute one of the fastest-growing religious categories in the United States. Since most of the nonreligious were raised in religious homes, their growth raises important questions about the mental health of those who consider dropping out of religion. In this article, I use longitudinal data from the Portraits of American Life Study to examine the impact of religious affiliation on mental health. Specifically, I compare individuals who dropped out of religion (leavers) with individuals who considered dropping out (stayers) and individuals who are more consistent in their religious (stable affiliates) and nonreligious (stable Nones) affiliations. I find that stayers experience more depressive symptoms than any other group and that they experience a greater increase in depressive symptoms over time. My findings are consistent with identity theories in sociology, and they provide evidence that a strong religious or secular identity is an important contributor to mental health.

Article first published online: December 29, 2017 May1Oakland University, Rochester, MI, USA
Corresponding Author: Matthew May, Department of Sociology, Anthropology, Social Work, and Criminal Justice, Oakland University, 371 Varner Drive, Rochester, MI 48309-4485, USA. Email: